Lunes, 22 Agosto 2016

Case of the three dead rabbits highlights absurdity of Mexican justice system*

Valora este artículo
(0 votos)

Heliodoro Morales Mendoza was at work in the municipal offices of the small Mexican town where he lives, when four armed police officers burst in and arrested him in front of his colleagues.

960Local councillor Heliodoro Morales Mendoza, third right, was at work when four armed police officers arrested him in front of his colleagues. Denied bail, he faces up to 10 years in prison. Photograph: Handout

Morales was denied bail and has been held in pre-trial detention for seven months; he is facing up to 10 years in prison.

His alleged offence is not corruption, kidnapping, drug trafficking or involvement with the many criminal factions which have unleashed bloodshed across the country.

Morales stands accused of killing three rabbits.

The case highlights the absurdity and inequity of a justice system in which less than 1% of crimes are punished; a system in which drug capos can repeatedly escape from high-security prisons and politicians can face credible allegations of money-laundering or drug trafficking with little consequence, yet prisoners accused of minor crimes can languish in overcrowded prisons for months – or even years.

Morales, from the mostly indigenous Zapotec town of Tlacolula de Matamoros in the southern state of Oaxaca, was arrested in January. He was charged under legislation governing serious crimes against biodiversity, which his lawyers say is intended to protect endangered species like jaguars and pumas.

The charge may be unusual, but his prolonged pre-trial detention is not: more than 100,000 prisoners – about 41% of the total prison population – have been refused bail while their cases drag through the notoriously slow system.

Ana Aguilar, director of projects at the Institute of Criminal Justice Procedure (IJPP), said that preventive detention had traditionally been used as a populist measure to generate public confidence in the justice system.

In June, the government implemented sweeping judicial reforms intended to address the abuse of preventive detention, and for the first time introduce a presumption of innocence.

“That’s how the system was designed, to be against the presumption of innocence. This case is a clear reflection of what we’re trying to change with the new system, but these cases are still happening,” Aguilar said.

Under the new legislation, prisoners like Morales who were remanded under the old system are entitled to have their preventive imprisonment reviewed. 

But the judge has so far refused, according to Morales’s lawyer, Rodolfo Moreno. “The judge is being very rigid and has rejected every appeal and effort to resolve this absurd case – something I see time and time again with indigenous defendants,” he said.

Since international human rights standards were incorporated into the Mexico constitution in 2011, judges are supposed to remand suspects only in the most serious circumstances, such as when there is a risk of flight or violence.

“You have to also take a step back from the judge and wonder why, when we have such big problems with organised crime and other important cases, that the public prosecutors think it’s worth putting resources into a case like this,” said Aguilar.

The alleged crime was committed in 2012, when Morales – a car mechanic and member of the local council – was clearing a plot of land where he grows maize and beans.

Court documents show that another family member admitted shooting the rabbits to police and paid a cash bond at the court, pending trial. But the case did not proceed, and was forgotten by the family.

More than three years later, Morales was arrested in the municipal government offices where he was serving as the public security councillor.

His relative’s admission of guilt was rejected by the judge, who is also demanding that Morales prove his ethnicity by appointing an anthropologist as an expert witness.More than three years later, Morales was arrested in the municipal government offices where he was serving as the public security councillor.

“Even if he had killed the rabbits, this is completely disproportionate. It could take another year to meet the judge’s demands, which is expensive and will cause even more damage to the whole family,” said Moreno.

Morales’s 22-year-old son, also called Heliodoro, is studying law, but he finds the case against his father incomprehensible.

“My dad has worked hard his whole life to give us opportunities he never had. We can’t understand why this has happened to him. We feel desperate.”

The severe response could in part be explained by the location of the alleged rabbit cull. Morales’s land lies within a large area which in 1998 was designated a protected zone because of its proximity to the important pre-Columbian archaeological site of Yagul.

Despite a legal requirement to inform landowners, none of the families with plots in the area were formally told of the new rules or offered alternative lands. So they continued farming.

Rabbits are often killed for food, or to control numbers when they became pests. They can be bought for as little as £2 (50 pesos) in the local market, according to the younger Morales.

“I’m reading law books at university but justice doesn’t exist in Mexico – the system just goes after people who can’t defend themselves,” he said. “There are murderers and kidnappers walking the streets and my father is in prison for killing three rabbits.”

*Publicado en theguardian.com [agosto 22, 2016]

Consulta también:

Modificado por última vez en Lunes, 22 Agosto 2016 11:01

28 comentarios

  • Enlace al Comentario supreme clothing Viernes, 30 Octubre 2020 01:32 publicado por supreme clothing

    I simply had to thank you very much yet again. I do not know the things I might have done without the type of suggestions discussed by you relating to that subject. This was the frightening crisis in my circumstances, however , discovering a new professional style you processed it took me to leap over gladness. I am happier for the guidance as well as hope you know what an amazing job you have been accomplishing instructing people via your blog post. I am certain you've never met any of us.

  • Enlace al Comentario success Viernes, 30 Octubre 2020 01:31 publicado por success

    I'm writing to make you understand of the amazing experience my wife's child obtained checking the blog. She mastered a wide variety of issues, which included what it is like to possess an ideal teaching nature to let the others clearly gain knowledge of specified hard to do topics. You truly exceeded readers' expected results. Thank you for imparting those good, safe, informative not to mention easy tips on this topic to Evelyn.

  • Enlace al Comentario golden goose sale Viernes, 30 Octubre 2020 01:31 publicado por golden goose sale

    I simply wanted to thank you very much once more. I am not sure the things that I would have done without those thoughts discussed by you directly on such question. It seemed to be the daunting scenario for me, nevertheless being able to see the very well-written manner you handled it forced me to weep for gladness. I am grateful for the guidance and as well , believe you find out what an amazing job you happen to be carrying out teaching some other people through your site. I'm certain you have never encountered any of us.

  • Enlace al Comentario lebron 15 Viernes, 30 Octubre 2020 01:31 publicado por lebron 15

    I together with my friends were going through the best advice from your website and then suddenly I got an awful suspicion I had not expressed respect to the blog owner for those tips. My guys had been thrilled to see them and have absolutely been having fun with those things. Thanks for being very kind and then for picking such fantastic topics most people are really desirous to be aware of. My personal sincere regret for not expressing appreciation to you earlier.

  • Enlace al Comentario giannis antetokounmpo shoes Viernes, 30 Octubre 2020 01:31 publicado por giannis antetokounmpo shoes

    I needed to compose you that very little note to help thank you very much again regarding the beautiful solutions you've documented on this page. It was really tremendously generous with you to provide without restraint exactly what a few individuals could possibly have offered for sale for an e-book to get some money for themselves, even more so considering that you might have tried it in the event you desired. Those thoughts in addition worked to be the good way to know that many people have the same desire like my own to learn more and more with regards to this issue. I'm certain there are millions of more pleasant sessions ahead for many who read your blog.

  • Enlace al Comentario StephenNains Martes, 27 Octubre 2020 07:24 publicado por StephenNains

    where to get viagra buy viagra online cheap viagra 100mg

  • Enlace al Comentario yeezy 350 Martes, 27 Octubre 2020 04:44 publicado por yeezy 350

    I simply needed to thank you very much yet again. I do not know the things that I might have taken care of in the absence of the type of advice shared by you directly on my subject. This has been an absolute frightening dilemma in my position, but being able to see the very specialised mode you dealt with the issue forced me to jump for contentment. Now i'm grateful for this help and hope you find out what a great job you have been undertaking teaching the others through the use of your web site. Probably you've never got to know any of us.

  • Enlace al Comentario supreme hoodie Martes, 27 Octubre 2020 04:44 publicado por supreme hoodie

    Thanks for all your valuable labor on this website. My aunt delights in doing investigation and it's easy to see why. A lot of people hear all about the dynamic means you offer helpful ideas via your web blog and even foster response from some others on the subject while our favorite child is certainly discovering so much. Take advantage of the rest of the year. Your carrying out a remarkable job.

  • Enlace al Comentario kobe 11 Martes, 27 Octubre 2020 04:44 publicado por kobe 11

    My husband and i felt now fulfilled Chris could conclude his basic research via the ideas he received when using the site. It is now and again perplexing to just continually be giving out helpful tips that many some people may have been selling. And we all grasp we need the writer to be grateful to for this. All the illustrations you've made, the easy web site navigation, the relationships you will aid to promote - it is many amazing, and it is making our son in addition to the family know that that subject matter is exciting, which is certainly extremely serious. Thanks for the whole thing!

  • Enlace al Comentario supreme new york Martes, 27 Octubre 2020 04:44 publicado por supreme new york

    My husband and i were very lucky that Louis managed to finish off his homework by way of the precious recommendations he grabbed when using the weblog. It's not at all simplistic just to happen to be giving out helpful hints that many other people could have been trying to sell. And we also see we now have you to thank because of that. The illustrations you made, the easy site menu, the relationships you assist to promote - it's got everything wonderful, and it is making our son in addition to our family reckon that this topic is excellent, which is truly vital. Many thanks for all!

Deja un comentario

Asegúrate de llenar la información requerida marcada con (*). No está permitido el código HTML. Tu dirección de correo NO será publicada.